THE WRITE STUFF
Bainbridge Teen Wins National Literary Prize
BY GEORGE SOLTES
Audrey Nelson debuted as a fiction writer at age 4 with “The Bunny and the Bear,” a short story about a rabbit who grows tired of being menaced by an aggressive bear and decides to trap him in a butterfly net. The story ends, in what Nelson laughingly described as a master twist, with the bunny family sitting down to a tasty bear dinner.
Fourteen years later, in May 2021, Nelson was a senior at Bainbridge High School working part-time at Liberty Bay Books in Poulsbo. “I was in the bookstore and my phone went off, but I had silenced it because I wasn't supposed to be looking at it,” Nelson recalled. As she continued to work, the store phone began ringing.
Nelson’s mother, Sarah Auerbach, was on the line with an urgent message. Michael Roth, the president of Wesleyan University in Middleton, Connecticut, one of the colleges to which Nelson had applied, needed to speak with her. Nelson returned the call from a back office and was told that her short story “Complications” had been awarded the Hamilton Prize for Creativity and had earned her a four-year, full-tuition scholarship to attend Wesleyan.
The Hamilton Prize was established by Wesleyan alumni Lin-Manuel Miranda and Thomas Kail, the Tony award winning collaborators behind the hit Broadway musicals “In the Heights” and “Hamilton.” Miranda explained in a press release why Nelson’s story had been chosen among hundreds of applicants for the grand prize: “Audrey’s ‘Complications’ was delightful and surprising at every turn: in structure, in subject matter, in its evocative language. I wanted to read more from this writer immediately.”
Nelson was born into a household where it was second nature to put her thoughts down on paper. Her grandmother, Jessica Auerbach, published four novels, including the bestselling “Sleep, Baby, Sleep,” which was made into an ABC network television movie. “I was really proud that my grandma had written books that we had on our shelves,” Nelson said. “I found that pretty amazing.” Sarah Auerbach is also a professional writer, with multiple romance novels published under the pseudonym Serena Bell. Nelson remembered sitting side by side with her mother at the kitchen table as a child, each of them working away at their writing.
—Sarah Auerbach Nelson’s prize-winning story almost didn’t happen. After deciding to enter the competition, she put off writing it. “I can’t do this,” she recalled thinking. “Lin-Manuel Miranda could be reading what I submit. There's no way I can send in any of my work. It's too embarrassing.” Finally, encouraged by her parents, she found a fragment of a story she had written for a sophomore English assignment. “It was pretty plotless and didn't have much actual substance,” she said. Taking those bare bones as her starting point, she completed “Complications,” a magic realist fable about a woman sent home from the maternity ward with a baby bird, in less than two hours. “The stuff I just blasted off was so much better than what I had worried over for weeks,” she said.
These days, Nelson is a busy freshman at Wesleyan. The former high school basketball star is trying her hand at rugby, which she described as “kind of scary but super fun.” She is undecided about whether she will make writing her career. Her father, Laird Nelson, is an accomplished musician who plays keyboards with local bands but makes his living as a software engineer. “I grew up in a family where my dad chose not to have his passion as his main source of work and my mom chose to do her passion as her work,” Nelson said. “I get both sides of it, and I see the pros and cons of both.” Whatever she decides, writing remains a big part of her life. She penned a short play called “Monstrous” which was just performed at a campus play festival and has submitted “Complications” to several literary magazines. She recently garnered her first rejection but took it in stride. “I was honestly super glad to get the first one,” she said. “I'm a real writer now! Look at this official rejection! It feels good.”

