SHIFTING SHORELINES
A Waterfront Home Shaped by Art, Nuance and an Ever-Changing Life
BY ALLI SCHUCHMAN | PHOTOGRAPHY BY CALEB MELVIN OF CLARITY NORTHWEST PHOTOGRAPHY
Lisa Wiggins’ Bainbridge Island home is made for looking outward, notably from its expansive deck—about 2,500 square feet—which has provided space to gather for graduations, casual hangouts, parties and celebrations. In hindsight, she said she might have chosen a smaller deck and more yard if she had been able to make every decision from scratch, but the space has proved invaluable.

Below the deck, a dock (frequented by Wilbur, a French bulldog donning his bright inflatable shark floatie) connects the house to the bay. She explained that the tide has its way with the shoreline and sometimes limits when a boat can get out at low water. But the ebb and flow open a different kind of access to the beach and its sea life. Sometimes, she said, the bay can feel lake-still with the jagged Olympic Mountains quietly sitting in the distance, while at other times visitors get a whole other perspective as the sun moves across the house throughout the day, eventually slipping behind the mountains.
Outside, the decks and gathering areas extend the house into the landscape. There are fire pits, a lounge area and room to spend time outdoors even when the weather is not summery. “We are able to be out there way more because we’re Seattleites,” she said. “We go out. It doesn’t have to be 80 degrees to be outside.”
But a close second to its Fletcher Bay location, the home’s next most distinctive feature is the restraint with which Wiggins—an interior designer specializing in commercial and multifamily properties—has shaped it. The serenity feels thoughtfully earned.
Wiggins said they bought the home in 2018 and felt an immediate connection to the property, writing a letter to its previous owners about imagining raising a family there in the hopes they’d understand the care she would take with the home. It wasn’t bluster. During the renovation, Wiggins even asked the crew to preserve a pony wall. “You could feel the love in it,” she recalled.
As often happens with a home makeover, when the walls came open, rot and structural problems appeared, and the renovation expanded into a near-total rebuild. The house was taken down to the studs. “Everything about it is brand new,” Wiggins said. The work also came with delays and disruption, and, after a permit issue, the family even moved to temporary rentals while the project stalled.

But today, the finished home reflects the setting as much as it does Wiggins’ eye. She wanted it “warm, but airy”—light enough to let the water command attention, yet comfortable enough to feel inhabited. She started with inspirations she’d already found—stone that would become the fireplace—then built a palette from there. “I just started building a color palette and then found the pieces that fit in.”
“I like things to have a purpose,” she added, describing her process. “A void is not a negative.” The philosophy, she explained, is more than just a decorating rule for her as a professional designer. Wiggins said that letting blank space be an active part of a room, and allowing the objects that matter become more visible, is key to how she creates.
Wiggins said that editing matters especially on the water, where light can transform the space and color. A paint that worked in one home may fall flat in another. “Your colors change so much,” she said. White, she noted, is among the hardest colors to get right: Its undertones can turn seemingly pink, gray or unexpectedly warm.
The rooms are not arranged around a rigid signature style either. Wiggins likes clean lines, but not a space that feels cold or overworked. She has a custom sofa, sized for the living room, and new pieces sit alongside items with personal histories. For example, a substantial rug was acquired when a friend was moving and then cut to fit the space. Elsewhere, older furniture and accessories contribute their own character.
Wiggins said that striking that balance begins with respect for what is already there. “I think you need to respect the house. You can’t force a style onto it.” She applies the same principle to her commercial work, where she has designed interiors for offices, multifamily properties and historic buildings. At Seattle’s Colman Building, for example, she took cues from the building’s original character rather than treating it as a blank canvas. “It’s not your portfolio; it’s their portfolio,” she said, pointing out that a material or trend that works in one project may be wholly wrong for another.

Her appreciation for vivid art provides a counterpoint to the quietness of the rooms. Several saturated pieces by Vancouver artist Stewart Stephenson bring bursts of color into the home. Wiggins first encountered one of his works and later bought it for her Seattle office. She admires the way he works across materials and, above all, the intensity of his use of color.
Other art pieces came from people close to her. A painting by her brother’s former boyfriend caught her eye and a photograph from her eldest daughter’s wedding in Bozeman, Montana, preserves the movement of the bride’s dress. There are pictures Wiggins brought back from New York, too. Together, the works shape less a formal collection than a record of people, places and moments she wants to keep near.
Although the compilation is impressive, Wiggins said that not every piece of art needs a price tag to matter. “I don’t even know that any of these have value.”
The striking kitchen is warm, with dark wood cabinetry and honed marble countertops, a surface Wiggins loves even while acknowledging its upkeep can be demanding. Throughout the entire home though, comfort is key and built into the less-visible details.
Ultimately, Wiggins said the rooms seem to hold that same combination of practicality and feeling: a former bedroom turned office, a kitchen desk area made into a wine closet, art kept because it matters and outdoor spaces ready for company. The house is not a static display of a finished life. It is a place Wiggins has shaped as her life has changed—comfortable, personal and open to whatever comes next.
And next is on the horizon. Wiggins is planning to leave for a year in May—leasing the house while she spends time with her 87-year-old mother in Bozeman. “It’s a growing urgency,” she said. Bainbridge, her Fletcher Bay home and all her friends will eagerly await her return.

