PEGASUS

How a mythical flying horse won over a legion of coffee lovers.

BY JEFF FRAGA | PHOTOS BY DINAH SATTERWHITE

Back when Starbucks was a fledgling business, a fanatical coffee devotee on Bainbridge Island was working to create the perfect coffee bean. Over the years, the coffee roaster—Pegasus founder David Dessinger—sought a roast that would show the island how flavorful coffee could be.

Mentored by none other than coffee aficionado Alfred Peet—founder of Peet’s Coffee— Dessinger finally developed the elusive formula that allowed Pegasus Coffee to bring a classic European-style coffee house to the Pacific Northwest.

And that was just the beginning. Dessinger also dreamed of re-creating the coffee house atmosphere he had loved in Berkeley, California: a place filled with lively discussions, live performances and local art. Pegasus quickly became a thriving gathering place and was named one of the best independent coffee shops in the world by the Financial Times in 2022.

“This coffee house has been a community hub on the island for more than 40 years,” said Matt Grady, president of Pegasus Coffee, who purchased the company in 2021. While Grady is fervent about coffee, he’s just as devoted to building on the arthouse feeling the place exudes. “Pegasus has always been more than a business,” he said. “Our team has also focused on creating safe meeting spaces for communities and supportive homes for local artists.”

Beyond its sustainably sourced, hand-roasted coffees and house-made food, Pegasus features ongoing events including live music, paint night, open mic night and bingo night.

Pegasus, 131 Parfitt Way, 206-317-6914 Pegasus continues to grow in other ways as well. “Last year, we joined forces to offer Bainbridge Island Museum of Art patrons a new Pegasus Coffee espresso bar as part of the museum’s redesigned BIMA Bistro,” said Grady.

Now about that flying horse...It turns out that Dessinger loved Greek mythology and was mulling ideas for the company name and logo when he was presented with the Pegasus option. “The flying horse was this inspirational kind of figure, and he just loved the connection to mythology,” said Grady.

Pegasus has been flying high ever since.