MORE THAN A CRUSH
Passion for Wine Making Drives the Island’s Artisan Vintners
BY JEFF FRAGA | PHOTOS COURTESY OF WINERY ALLIANCE OF BAINBRIDGE ISLAND
Yes, wine.
Fact is, Bainbridge Island keeps producing more and more award-winning wines, and today the wine industry here is more robust than ever. Each of the Island’s seven wineries takes a unique approach to crafting wine. And you’ll get a truly one-of-a-kind tasting experience at each.
With the annual wine crush happening this time of year, we thought it would be the right moment to take a look at each of Bainbridge’s wineries—and winemakers—along with their unique perspective and approach to winemaking.
Recognizing that wine is often served with food, Amelia Wynn owner and vintner Paul Bianchi has turned his cozy bistro on Winslow Way into a tasting room. Or is it the other way around? The bistro features Iberian Peninsula-inspired cuisine, local and seasonal ingredients and house-made desserts. An Amelia Wynn wine tasting is offered daily.
Speaking of wines, Bianchi said his goal in making wines is simple: “We want to source the best quality grapes from vineyards with consistent vintages.” This approach has resulted in numerous prestigious awards for Amelia Wynn, including the recent Best of Class 97 pt. Red Mt. Cabernet Sauvignon from the 2022 Sunset International Wine Competition, and a past Best of Show for the winery’s 2016 Grenache Noir Aragon.
Fletcher Bay Winery holds the distinction of having the tasting room closest to the ferry. From its humble start in owner/ founder/winemaker Jim Wilford’s garage in 2008, Fletcher Bay has grown to be popular not only with wine fans but also with music lovers, thanks to a full schedule of live music at both the winery’s Winslow Way and Coppertop locations. Wilford also has secured the rooftop above its Winslow tasting room, full time, year-round, opening up new opportunities for events and musical performances.
And that’s all in addition to Fletcher Bay’s award-winning wines. “Every year we reserve the best quality grapes we can possibly find,” said Wilford. “So, we expect the quality will get even better each year.”
He added: “Other than that, we’re in a very good place and don’t see much changing.”
Alphonse de Klerk is obsessed with winemaking. “My first wine crush was in 1978,” said de Klerk. “I was 28 years old.” He was a home winemaker from 1986 to 2006 before launching Rolling Bay Winery in 2007.
How are de Klerk’s wines different from other Bainbridge wines? “All the wines are different, so it’s hard to generalize,” he said. “But in a nutshell, I’d say we're more interested in fruit than tannins, more in search of elegance than boldness.”
To de Klerk, the biggest challenge of making wine is simply that the winemaker doesn’t have much time to get everything right. “Thirty vintages means there’s only 30 times that you get to try to get everything to sync up,” he said. “That’s not really a lot when you think about it.”
Perennial Vintners began in 1997, when Mike Lempriere decided to learn about wine by making it. He began to understand that 95 percent of winemaking is truly done in the vineyard and that making his own wines was not enough. “It was necessary to live upon and manage the vineyard to gain the insights it takes to truly become a wine maker,” he said. So, he moved in 2003 to Bainbridge Island, where he lives in a house surrounded by grape vines.
He wants Perennial Vintners to be the kind of place where visitors can buy a bottle of wine and enjoy a picnic next to the very grapes that will become Perennial’s future wines “Either the winemaker or the owner will be serving your wine,” said Lempriere. “It's a very personal experience. We try really hard to be informative and interesting, and not just another wine tasting.”
Eagle Harbor Winery winemaker Emily Parsons liked the wines from Eagle Harbor Wine Company so much that she bought the winery. That was in 2014. Today she carries on the tradition of making wines that are elegant, balanced and approachable. “We're still sourcing really good grapes, we’re still hand sorting and we still use our same fermentation process.”
At the same time, Parsons is introducing some new barreling techniques. “I match the barrel and the forest that the barrels coopered from to the varietal that I put in the barrel,” she said.” That allows the wines to mature by lengthening the tannins, producing a smoother, more ready-to-drink wine.”
Any other changes in mind? “Just that as our reputation for making good wine gets better, we have access to better and better grapes,” she said. “And, of course, better grapes make better wine.”
Bainbridge Vineyards is one of two Bainbridge wineries that grow grapes on the island. “We’re quite proud of that,” said owner-winemaker Betsey Wittick. “In addition to being 100 percent estate grown, all our vineyards are certified organic.” Her winery is also the first in Washington State to be B-Corp Certified, a recognition that it meets the highest social and environmental standards.
The vineyard’s first vines were planted in 1977; today Bainbridge Vineyards grows 10 varietals on 8 acres of estate vineyards. From there, the winery produces about 1,200 cases per year, with a focus on wines that are delicate and aromatic. “The Puget Sound Region has the kind of cool climate that these grapes love,” said Wittick.
With its wines 100 percent island grown, crushed and bottled, it’s easy to see just how passionate Bainbridge Vineyards is about creating wine from the ground up.
Owner and winemaker Matt Albee sums up what Eleven Winery is all about: Eleven is 100 percent committed to “making great wine, making it fun and making the world a better place.
“We strive to make our wines better each vintage,” he said. “We create a fun experience for all visitors to our tasting room, regardless of their level of wine knowledge. We seek to work sustainably and to work with vineyards that do the same. We donate to local and global nonprofits—especially those that are bike-related. And we support local nonprofits in their fundraising efforts, especially those focused on education and poverty.”
As for the wines themselves, Eleven emphasizes maximizing varietal fruit expression—using only enough oak to enhance those flavors, not to stand out as a flavor on its own.
Ultimately, Albee said, Eleven succeeds when people think of it as a fun place to taste great wine, with lots of different wines to try.

