MATTERS OF THE HART

Home Renovation Confirms Adage that Nothing Can be Easy

BY ALLI SCHUCHMAN | PHOTOS BY DAVID WHITE COHEN

 

In late 2019, Bill and Stacy Austin heard that a neighbor’s house—just around the corner from their own on the southwest side of the Meadowmeer golf community—was about to come onto the market.

A flurry of activity at the property preparing for its sale piqued Bill’s curiosity, so he decided to drop by. »

“I drove up the driveway to the center tree and stopped,” he said. “I thought, oh my god, Stacy’s got to see this house.”

It was love at first sight for her, too, just as Bill had predicted. “I mean, it needed a lot of work, but look at it,” she said. “The beams, the woodwork, the layout. It was just amazing.”

Plus, the house was in the neighborhood Stacy cherished. “Because of the way Hart Lane bends, our old backyard looks through this backyard,” she explained. “You can see the green. It’s just lovely. It feels like there’s no one back there.”

Bill said that Stacy went as far as writing a letter to the former owner promising to honor the property’s essence should their offer be accepted. And despite the home attracting throngs of interested buyers, the Austins’ bid, and sentiments, won out.

The idea of a renovation project didn’t concern the Austins, both of whom had spent their careers in the homebuilding industry, Bill in carpentry and Stacy in project management, including her current role with Clark Construction. Their gameplan was straightforward. “We were going to add a bathroom, turn the room upstairs into our bedroom, and the rest of it was just going to be interior finishes. Easy enough,” said Stacy. “And then we started getting into some things.”

One of the first undertakings was to create more room in the home’s upper level. “We basically took off the second story to change the pitch of the roof and reframe it all. We tore off the roof on January 2, 2020,” said Stacy, “and then it rained every single day in January. Every. Single. Day.”

“We still have the 50-foot by 50-foot tarp,” said Bill.

Rain was just the beginning. Over the next several months, the Austins’ biblical plague bingo card would continue to be impressively filled.

While moving some furniture left behind by the previous owner, the couple’s next hurdle turned out to be beady-eyed. “Rats had been living under a dresser. It was disgusting,” said Stacy, who explained that it wasn’t until they started removing the kitchen cabinetry that they grasped the full scope of the rodent problem. “Every hole in the wall, had ‘that’ smell. They were absolutely everywhere. So, we were down to studs.”

The infestation necessitated removing all but one of the interior walls, all the insulation and rewiring the entire home.

Next, while looking into why the crawlspace was flooding, the Austins discovered that instead of being properly placed next to the footer, the footing drain had been incorrectly placed on top of it. “Water was just pouring into the foundation,” said Stacy. “We ended up having to tear the deck off the back to put in the footing drain. It was just one thing after another.”

And then COVID hit. “Of course we were living next door,” said Stacy. “I’m panicking because now we have two houses. We were doing everything we could—working day and night—just to get the house to a point where we could move in.” While Stacy laid flooring, Bill laid tile. “So, we moved very early into a construction zone,” said Stacy.

Thankfully, their former home sold immediately and the Austins were in— albeit in less-than-ideal fashion—by April 2020. They were then able to turn their attention back to their original, more esthetic list of renovations.

The signature fir beams that crisscross the open design were stripped of their orangey paint and the focal point floating stairway’s dated wooden balusters were replaced with sleek black steel newels and wire. The staircase was also reconfigured to have a single run, square to the front door, instead of its previous configuration that jogged 90 degrees into the family room.

The kitchen got all new cabinets and quartz countertops, stainless appliances and lighting. The Austins also installed new maple flooring, new trim and doors throughout, and a granite slab floor at the entry to match the fireplace hearth. The fireplace is surrounded by built-in bookcases that Bill made and sits under a bright clerestory window, which brings much-welcomed light from their forested homesite.

Off the main living area is teenage son, Grayson’s, domain—a modest bedroom connected to a generously sized rec room for gaming, homework and hanging with friends.

The fresh upper level—complete with its new higher ceilings—is home to the Austins’ bright primary bedroom suite, which looks out onto the golf course’s 5th fairway. Also on the upper level is Stacy’s office. An adjacent storage nook does double duty as a retreat for their golden retriever, Briggan, named after a wolf from fantasy literature despite lacking his namesake’s storied luxurious coarse gray-white fur, keen claws and savage teeth.

For the exterior’s refresh, the Austins extended the tigerwood deck and even unearthed a pond just off the entry. The removal of a couple of trees, along with loads of fallen limbs and brush, made way for lush plants and a walkway now complemented by the gentle sound of trickling water.

Next to the home is (mostly) Bill’s workshop, where in addition to doing carpentry, he painstakingly handmakes the guitars that adorn the home’s walls.

Though he’s prolific—his attention is currently focused on a bouzouki, a cousin to the bass mandolin—he doesn’t sell the stunning instruments, but uses them himself, noting that he’s “played a little for 45 years.” In a back corner of the shop, Stacy makes glass beads with a torch and colored rods. She’s given some away as gifts. “I’m aspiring,” she said, modestly brushing off any compliments.

Down the road, Stacy can envision turning the shop into a mother-in-law apartment, where they could potentially live if their son comes back to live on Bainbridge after college.

“Eventually in time, when you’ve stopped building guitars.”

Would they have taken the project on if they knew what they were getting into? Tough to say. But at least for today, the Austins are content in the notion of never, ever again.