LEADING LADIES

The Women Guiding Bainbridge’s Faith Communities

BY CONNIE BYE | PHOTOS BY ANNIE GRAEBNER

As the number of female religious leaders rises nationwide, five Bainbridge congregations are

already led by women. Their tenures range from Rev. Erin Grayson, who became pastor at Bethany Lutheran Church on February 1, to Rev. Dee Eisenhauer, who started at Eagle Harbor Congregational Church in 1999. Following a brief break after college, Eisenhauer plunged into the ministry. “I was shy, but I found out I was pretty good at this,” she said. “I’ve been here longer than I expected. But this is a delightful place to work; the broader community here is wonderful.”

For some of the other women, becoming a minister was a dream postponed or a second career.

Rev. Karen Haig, rector at St. Barnabas Episcopal Church, was ordained in 2010. Before pursuing the ministry, she co-founded and worked for Earth and Space Research, a nonprofit in Seattle focused on oceanographic research.

Haig, who has lived on Bainbridge for 40 years, said she’s grateful to have become a minister when she did. “I was a single mom before and couldn’t have afforded it,” she said. “Motherhood was my first profession; the priesthood was my second.”

Haig is mindful that women haven’t always been permitted to do her job and that some religious groups still do not allow females to lead congregations. A few members left St. Barnabas when she became the first female lead priest, “but very few.”

Grayson said even well-meaning people struggle sometimes with accepting a woman at the pulpit. After all, it was a male-dominated position for centuries.

“Some people say, ‘Good job,’ after I lead a service,” she said, as if it’s bit surprising. “I’ve had people—not here— say, ‘It would be good if you’d wear a dress sometimes.’”

Susan Griggs, pastor at Seabold United Methodist Church, had a first career as a school psychologist and volunteered as a lay minister. But after her husband died in an accident and she received an insurance payout, she “realized I could afford to become a pastor.”

She worked at two churches in Connecticut before moving to Washington to be near her family. Griggs eventually retired from the ministry but was asked to return in 2019 and came to Seabold last July. She noted that she replaced another female pastor, Cindy Roberts.

Griggs, 72, considers it a key responsibility to advocate for social justice. She has delivered sermons on Hamas and Israel, as well as the Palestinian situation, urging the congregation to consider what Jesus would think. At Pride festivals last year in Poulsbo and Bainbridge, her message was: You are beloved, just as you are, by God.

“I will speak up,” Griggs said. “When I interviewed here, one person said, ‘Good. My daughter will have a strong woman to look up to.’”

REACHING A BROADER COMMUNITY The five women often come together for a brown-bag lunch that’s open to clergy of any gender. “Sometimes, we go deep, but mostly we talk. We know we can find instant support or a place to vent,” Grayson said. “If I’m stumped or lost, it’s always wise counsel.”

There’s much to share. Like her peers, Griggs has been frustrated that people did not return to church in the same numbers after COVID. She’s been brainstorming new ways to draw in the community, including possible Saturday night services followed by a shared meal.

“A lot of things stopped because of COVID,” said Rev. Karen Renner, senior pastor at Rolling Bay Presbyterian Church. “Now, we’re asking what do we want to bring back? What needs to be retired?”

Eisenhauer said she’s been through crises before, but COVID was exceptionally tough. “One thing the pandemic really broke was our relationship with young families,” she said. “It’s caused a lot of grief in this congregation.”

COVID also spawned isolation, sadness and depression for old and young people alike. “Our mission emphasis this past year or so is to reduce the epidemic of loneliness,” Eisenhauer said, “and to listen to people who have stories to tell.”

Renner has worked in the ministry for nearly 30 years. After stints at churches in Texas, Kansas, Oregon and elsewhere in Washington, she came to Bainbridge in 2022—her first time as a lead minister.

Church attendance was “all over the place” Renner’s first year but has stabilized. “We do Advent and Lenten dinners—supper with a small discussion. We filled up the room for Advent with people of all ages. Now we’re wondering if we want to make this a regular thing.”

Also, Rolling Bay Presbyterian has made a commitment to meeting needs of the surrounding neighborhood, Renner said. To that end, it offers community garden plots, and it opened an indoor play space to young families who had been using the church’s outdoor playground during warmer weather.

“Who are the people in the neighborhood we aren’t talking to?” Renner said. “We’re hoping to lean into that in 2024.”

Grayson, too, sees the beauty in considering traditions and needs from fresh perspectives. During Lent last year, Bethany established a prayer wall in the sanctuary and set up a large bowl of sand, “where people could simply feel the sand, write in the sand, mess it up sometimes and wipe it clean.” Much like our sometimes-messy lives, she noted.

Grayson came to Bethany in 2022 after working as an associate pastor at Rolling Bay Presbyterian; she was recruited by Rev. Paul Stumme-Diers, who retired early this year. Her initial job at Bethany was faith formation, including education, fellowship, social justice programs and some preaching. Now, she is tasked with ministering to the congregation while it considers her and other candidates to be Bethany’s permanent pastor.

AN INTENSE DELIGHT Traditionally, females have been socialized since childhood to care about others, Eisenhauer said, which can be an asset in the ministry. “A colleague and I were chatting, and he said, ‘It’s that relationship thing.’ He just didn’t have that naturally. He puts a lot of his energy into preaching.”

Haig said she treasures “walking alongside people in the most tender and rich moments of their lives.” She noted that three of St. Barnabas’ assisting priests also are women; all retired and unpaid. “They do this from the goodness of their hearts and generosity. They have been wonderful counsel for me.”

Women often are collaborative rather than top-down managers, also a plus in the ministry, Renner said. “I like hearing other people’s ideas. And I get along well with people of all ages.”

Many women share a common interest in dismantling systems of control and patriarchy, Eisenhauer said. “The more women have a baked-in understanding of how patriarchy operates, the better off we all are.”

Grayson said a major goal is to make worship as inclusive as possible. “We’re challenging people to not simply see God as a white, old man in the sky.” She added: “Church only comes alive as a community when people see a place for themselves in it.”

Griggs said she relishes getting “to spend time with congregants, to know them well, to have them trust me. The feeling of connection can be so intense. That’s just a delight.”

She hopes there will be more and more equality in the world, including in the ministry, and that someday it won’t be remarkable for a woman to accomplish anything. “When first becomes second, then third—then it’s not a novelty anymore.”