IF WALLS COULD TALK
An Island Landmark Gets a Second Life
BY ALLI SCHUCHMAN | PHOTOS BY DAVID COHEN
The Laurels was formally recognized as a landmark by the Bainbridge Island Historical Register in 2020.
Built by Elias Nelson in 1913, the bungalow drew its romantic name from the heritage laurel hedge which surrounds its iconic mosaic stone entry arch. Today, thanks to painstaking renovation and refurbishment by its new owners, Myra and Tom Hudson, it has many colorful years ahead of it, too. » Sited on compass points with its front door opening to the east, Nelson built the home on his poultry farm while he worked as the chef at the Moran School for Boys just up the street. “I think how incredible that must have been in 1913 to build this house with hand tools, what this island must have been like,” said Myra.
While preparing The Laurels’ portfolio for the register’s accreditation, Myra unearthed a trove of history, from its heirloom apple trees to the stone and Douglas fir building materials that were sourced on site. Myra also discovered some pearls about the people who have called The Laurels home over the past century. She learned that the second owners were the Jones family, some of whose children still live on the island, including one of their daughters. “She was born in this house during a snowstorm. They couldn’t get down to the doctor, so she was born right here,” said Myra. “I just feel the spirit of all the people that lived here.”
The renovation was spearheaded by Tom, a professional contractor who owns local building company Hudson Construction, Inc. Like Myra’s research, the construction uncovered remarkable details about the home, including a massive 35-foot fir beam that runs the length of the porch. Because of its size and variety, Tom said the beam was most likely sourced, milled and dried on Bainbridge, perhaps from the site itself. “Thinking about those men raising that beam is fascinating,” said Myra. “We’re awed by the sheer effort it must have taken in those days.”
The Laurels is the Hudsons’ third home together since they married in 1971. The couple first lived in Colorado Springs before moving to Bainbridge three decades ago. Originally, they were considering The Laurels, which faces onto Sunrise Drive in the Rolling Bay Neighborhood just south of Bay Hay and Feed, as more of an investment than as their personal residence. While musing its purchase, the couple brought along their friend, Bainbridge architect Seri Yeckel, with whom Tom has often worked professionally. While walking the property together, they started to see it in a different light. “This house and our other house were the same vintage,” said Tom, comparing it to their former home on Pine Street in the Eagledale neighborhood. “I just like the feeling in an older home.”
After deciding to keep The Laurels for themselves, the Hudsons closed on the two-acre property in January 2018. Yeckel began working on the design and two months later they had the renovation permit in hand. For the next little while, things got messy, or as Myra likes to say, “All hell broke loose.”
“This place was just totally torn up,” said Tom. “Walls were missing, and the front room and porch were filled with furniture and stuff from our other house.”
With renovation under way, and The Laurels not yet habitable, the couple rented an ADU from a friend. “It was nice, except it was kind of like being in college again,” said Myra. “There were no cooking facilities, so we ate out every night, either with friends or in a restaurant. We used to tease them that they were adopting us, the orphans.”
After a lot of making do—including not one, but two (funny now) late night run-ins with bats—the Hudsons moved in two days before Christmas, just in time to host the holiday with son Sam and daughter Claire, their respective spouses and grandkids.
The Hudsons’ goal for The Laurels’ renovation was to preserve its “character and architectural authenticity,” while bringing it up to date structurally and making it functionable and livable. The Hudsons added roughly 750 square feet to the home’s footprint by bumping out the back and south walls, swapping the space that was the kitchen with the primary bedroom and bath, and adding a brand-new central kitchen on the home’s south side.
Major renovation items—including leveling and reinforcing the original foundation, a complete fireplace restoration, removal of several interior walls and the addition of the new kitchen, pantry and main-level laundry room—required forethought to create a “seamless, sensitive connection between the old house and new additions,” said Tom.
To keep the original interior shiplap siding and trim, the renovation took an outside-in approach. The asymmetrical exterior cedar shingles were removed so that all new electrical, plumbing and HVAC could be placed, after which exterior plywood was installed and covered with new cedar shingles.
Tom’s design ideas are seen throughout the home—including the custom cabinetry in the kitchen, pantry, laundry, bedrooms, bathrooms and wine cellar—all fashioned in Hudson Construction’s cabinet shop, as were the raised-panel interior doors designed to replicate the originals. Throughout The Laurels, a commingling of old and new reinforces the house’s continuity. Light switches replaced with vintage button switches, antique drawer pulls used on new cabinetry, restoration of aged door and window hardware and an integration of antique and new custom cabinetry are some of the areas where the warm juxtaposition shows up.
The kitchen is perhaps the home’s most striking feature. An absence of upper cabinetry lends extra wall space for the couple’s eclectic and extensive art collection, much of it crafted by island artisans and friends. Myra, who loves to cook and entertain, worked closely with Yeckel to imagine the kitchen’s deep drawers, soapstone counters, farm sinks and multiple shared work areas. “She’s extremely gifted,” said Myra of Yeckel. “She just has a way of hearing you.”
At the kitchen’s center sits a custom trestle table that Myra said was completely Tom’s vision. Made from Wenge, an African hardwood, Tom described it as nearly indestructible, able to withstand the rough and tumble nature of grandchildren, real life living and entertaining. The addition of windows and skylights funnels in natural light and bright white paint balances the dark wood trim.
Just off the kitchen, the butler’s pantry is highlighted by custom glass cabinet doors from the Mesolini Glass Studio. The Hudson’s former home had a similar pantry, and every time they had a party, they recalled there would be 10 or 15 people who would congregate there, so it was a must-have in The Laurels too.
The kitchen floor is slate and, like the table, is designed to hold up over time. “In this climate you can walk in with wet muddy feet and you haven’t ruined it,” said Myra. “If you have dogs or children, or if your shoes collect gravel. It’s another thing that we learned after living here for 30 years.”
Also central to the home is the original clinker brick fireplace. “As things go, it’s not an elegant fireplace, but it was built in 1913,” said Myra. The fireplace was crumbling and when the Hudsons rebuilt it, they discovered that it had been vented directly into the wall, having luckily never caught the house on fire. Now, complete with a proper box that flues into the chimney, Tom said it draws incredibly well. “One little twig there with a piece of paper and it will start right up.”
Upstairs are two bedrooms, a totally rebuilt bathroom and “Tom’s hangout,” where he carves and paints an impressive collection of ducks and birds and works on his burgeoning oil painting. The room’s wooden walls had been painted blue and the Hudsons experimented with varnishing them but were disappointed with the look. So, Tom took them down, flipped them over to reveal their unpainted side and hide the old paint, and reattached them. They also added transoms (which they’d carried with them since moving from Colorado) which bring more light into the space, and enclosed an east-facing deck to create a bright sun porch.
Myra pointed out that they kept the fir floor, although it’s a bit uneven, and chose not to add baseboards or quarter rounds, keeping with the original design. Throughout the renovation, embracing the home’s imperfections helped the Hudsons preserve its charm. As an example, Myra pointed out where the floorboards in the living room aren’t Over the years, they have had six labs, including their two current English labs. “The teenager is Jake,” said Tom, “and that senior statesman lady is Gamble. Gamble came with her name. We tried to change it, but she wouldn’t come.” Each day, Tom walks the neighborhood with Jake, who has a good deal of energy and an insatiable propensity for sniffing. “I think he could probably have a second career working for TSA or drug enforcement.”
Though they’re clearly beloved family members, Tom threatens that they will be the last dogs they’ll get. “You never know,” said Myra. “He might let me have more.” Conversely, Tom wouldn’t be opposed to renovating yet another house, while for Myra, this one is it.
“One of my favorite sayings is to never let your daughter marry a contractor,” she said, “but luckily I have an incredibly talented one.”
“Who’s that?” said Tom.
exactly straight and, in places, don’t meet up precisely. “There are some quirky things about the house,” she said, “but that’s the character.”
The Hudson’s Labradors are an unmissable part of the home’s character.

