EVERYBODY IN

How One Woman Turned Bainbridge Girls Water Polo Into a Culture of Leadership, Kindness and Championship Play

BY SHERI RENNER | PHOTOS BY KAYLA LIGHTFOOT

 

When Ruthie Screen first showed up for water polo around age 10, she wore a long-sleeved swimsuit so baggy that Bainbridge coach Kristin Gellert recalled her having to fling the sleeves forward as she swam. Eventually, Gellert stepped in. Maybe it was time for a different suit.

This past spring, Screen was an all-state player on Bainbridge High School’s undefeated girls state championship team. Now she helps coach some of the program’s youngest players. That progression from beginner to teammate to leader to coach is key to how Bainbridge water polo works.

Unlike larger programs that may have 40-plus players try out before cuts, Bainbridge does not have enough players to field both varsity and JV teams. That means newcomers play varsity, because, well, that’s all there is. “As a result, no one can hide,” said Gellert.

The small roster has its advantages. Players get more touches on the ball, more repetitions in the water and more responsibility. Experienced athletes learn patience by helping newer teammates understand drills; in the process, they become better players and leaders themselves.

That patience comes from memory. Almost everyone remembers what it felt like to be new. “Nobody grows up watching water polo on TV,” Gellert noted. Players may arrive having to learn everything from treading water to catching and throwing with one hand. Unlike athletes who began sports early in grade school, water polo players often started playing recently enough to remember that intimidating first day and who helped them through it.

Gellert began coaching Bainbridge’s Water Polo program in 2008 and now leads the boys and girls high school teams as well as the club program. In 2021, she became the first female coach in Washington to lead a boys water polo team to a state championship; with the girls’ 2026 title, she became the first female coach to win state championships with both genders. She also serves as team leader for USA Water Polo’s Women’s Development Team, works at Woodward Middle School and has two sons involved in the sport.

Her emphasis on ownership gives players plenty of room to lead. Once the team learns its warmup, they run it themselves. At the end of practices and games, they do shout-outs, recognizing teammates who did something well. Sometimes, Gellert quietly asks a senior to make sure a newcomer hears their name, too.

Gellert, who has a master’s degree in applied sport psychology, teaches players to be thermostats, not thermometers. “A thermometer measures the temperature. A thermostat sets it,” she said. On this team, leadership took different forms. Allie Paulson-Houser set the tone and energy. Audrey Keigley pushed the pace. Freshman Harper Rich kept fun at the forefront without letting up on the work. “She plays her best when she’s having fun with her friends,” Gellert said. That balance became part of the team’s strength.

The mental work is matched by physical demands. Sometimes the girls went straight from lifting heavy weights into matches, preparing them to compete hard for four quarters and beyond. “They loved feeling strong, and they loved working hard,” Gellert said.

And then there was Curtis.

Bainbridge had lost to Curtis Senior High School in the state final two years in a row, with one loss coming down to a single goal near the end. After one of those defeats, Gellert borrowed a line from “Ted Lasso” for the locker room: “There’s only one thing worse than being sad, and that’s being alone and sad, and nobody on this team is alone.”

“We didn’t want to have to have that talk again,” she said.

When Bainbridge opened the 2026 season against Curtis, the girls jumped out to an early lead. For a team accustomed to being the underdog, the feeling shifted. What if this is our year?

Bainbridge went undefeated and met four-time defending champion Curtis once more in the state final. When the match went to overtime, Gellert saw no panic. “It was just more water polo we got to play with each other,” she said.

Six more minutes. Game on. Rich scored the winning goal in Bainbridge’s 7-6 victory and was named tournament MVP.

For Gellert, though, the championship is only one measure of what the team has built. Kindness is another. “We’re not raising good athletes. We’re raising good humans,” she said. “Players can be fierce competitors while still showing up for one another with respect and kindness.”

When Gellert thinks about what she hopes these athletes remember 20 years from now, she doesn’t start with the championship. “The wins and losses become a faint memory,” she said. “I hope they remember feeling empowered, working toward something bigger than themselves and feeling supported as they grew into adults. Who they become is the measure that matters most.”