CHAI LOVE YOU, DARJEELING

Budding Tea Trade Adds an Air of Civility to Winslow

BY CONNIE BYE

Forget the Northwest’s coffee-swilling image, it’s teatime on Bainbridge Island.

Islanders are turning to tea to help ward off the negatives surrounding the pandemic, said Erika Thayer, who opened the Bainbridge Apothecary and Tea Shop in mid-2020 on Winslow Way. People crave health, a bit of normalcy and simple pleasures, she said.

“Tea is the perfect vehicle for that. It’s food for the soul; it tastes good and makes you feel good,” said Thayer, a Bainbridge resident for a dozen years. “You take some leaves, add water and find civility.”

People have been brewing tea for at least 3,000 years, Thayer noted, and it ranks only behind water on numerous lists of the world’s favorite beverages.

Toby Calabrese understands the appeal. She, her 13-year-old daughter Grace and other relatives celebrate special occasions at Thayer’s tea shop.

“Coffee revs you up,” Calabrese said. “Sipping tea makes you relax. It makes you feel like you’re on vacation.”

A few blocks away, Andrea and Joe Raetzer opened Steepologie Teas in November 2020 on Madrone Lane; last fall, they debuted their very first tea bar nearby. They own five Steepologies in the Seattle region.

The couple fell in love with Bainbridge 25 years ago and returned nearly every year, Joe Raetzer said via email. They were drawn to Madrone Lane’s “beautiful mixture of shops,” and when they heard some stores closed during the pandemic, “we reached out to the landlord to see if would be a good fit, and it was.”

Two longtime Bainbridge enterprises, Churchmouse Yarns & Teas and Paraffine, closed their physical stores during the pandemic but continue to sell specialty teas online.

But perhaps no one else strives as hard to create an ambience as Thayer. Her Le Cordon Bleu training is reflected in the pastries and other treats that her shop sells; she makes many of them. In selecting the 60 teas for the shop, she relied on nearly 30 years’ experience in the industry, including a stint as a tea master in Utah. The delicate, vintage cups and saucers that customers use are “little warriors of civility,” she said.

Customers can sip and chat at intimate booths inside the front door or linger out back inside a covered, draped, cushiony, heated patio oasis, where Carrotcake, a curly-tailed cat, often ambles up to greet visitors. “She came to us as a stray,” Thayer said. “And she’s been here the entire time.”

Farther out back, there’s a taco stand and seasonal ice cream shop. The Apothecary next door sells products that promote health and a sense of well-being. Thayer contends everything works well together.

When Thayer opened in July 2020, she said pandemic restrictions meant business “was really slow at first. That’s when local people really supported me.”

Among those loyalists is Calabrese, who moved from Houston to Bainbridge Island in March 2020 and discovered Thayer’s shops soon after they launched. Since then, she’s organized numerous tea parties and special events for family and friends. And she hired Thayer to handle the culinary details for her backyard wedding last summer.

“We had high tea after the ceremony,” Calabrese said. “Then we had a sunset dinner at our house. Erika catered the whole thing. She’s brilliant when it comes to food.”

Thayer estimates she’s done more than 200 birthday parties. She said she enjoys helping people plan tea events for groups of friends; tea celebrations for holidays, including Mother’s Day; or high tea, complete with baked treats, soup, scones, preserves, chocolate confections and more.

“We even turned (the patio) into a Jolly-Roger, pirate-themed tea party for some little boys,” she said.

She also welcomes off-island tea enthusiasts and novices. Her shops are some of the first and last things visitors and tourists encounter as they walk around Winslow Way and head back to the ferry.

Despite all this love of tea, she’s not a coffee hater. She estimated that 20 percent of her business is cups of hot joe.

“Even I drink a cup of coffee sometimes,” Thayer said with a smile. “I serve really good coffee.”