BETTER TOGETHER
Honoring History by Reconciling Old and New
BY ALLI SCHUCHMAN | PHOTOS BY DAVID W COHEN
As a young girl, Dennon spent summers in the cabin. The property on which it sits was a wedding gift to her parents Dorthea and Maurice “Mose” Vining from Dorthea’s parents, Mr. and Mrs. Daniel Pratt. The Pratts divided the beachfront property; they kept the southern part for their home and gave the land next door to the newlyweds. Traveling back and forth to the island from Seattle, Mose painstakingly built the original cabin by hand in 1932.
As an adult, Dennon and her husband, Jerry, took ownership of the properties. As Dennon puts it, “from Pratt to Vining to Dennon.”
The Daniels lived off Hidden Cove on the north end of the island, but had always wished for a place by the water. They didn’t have any luck finding a property until late 2017, when they caught wind that the southern Pratt property, with its 1960s home, was on the market.
“We looked at it and I was like, oh my God,” said Mo. The Daniels fell hopelessly in love. In an urgent push, they prepped, staged and listed their former home in four days and had it under contract within a week. Their hustle paid off. They closed on the Crystal Springs property in March 2018 and settled into their new home. Dennon, living in the beach cabin to the north, was their next-door neighbor.
The calm didn’t last for long. “Probably five months later,” said Mo, “Anne comes out to me in the driveway and tells me she’s going to sell her house, that it was becoming too much to handle. I was like, hold on, and literally ran back to our house to tell Tom.”
Tom didn’t hesitate. After living near the old cabin for a few months, the Daniels had come to cherish its charm and history and worried that another buyer might simply choose to raze it. “Just give us a chance to buy it,” he said. “We would love nothing more than to put these two properties back together.” Thankfully, Dennon also wanted to see the property regain its original integrity. She offered it to the Daniels before it went on the market, telling Mo, “It was meant to be one piece.”
“Rather than sell for the absolute highest price possible,” Tom reflected, “Anne took a chance on us and gave us a wonderful opportunity.”
After the sale, Dennon rented back the cabin from the Daniels for a year before moving to a cottage on her son’s property at the end of 2019.
The years had been hard on the cabin. The Daniels had initially planned to simply fix it up but, with greater scrutiny, realized it needed more than a mere Band-Aid. “We started a whole renovation,” said Mo. “We were trying to figure out how to preserve this house to retain its charm and not ruin it with just cheap updates–to honor the history of it.” The skill and labor that had gone into the original construction of the cabin were never far from their minds.
“We brought everything we possibly could up to today's codes and standards while respecting the craftmanship, quality and attention to detail as Maurice did,” said Tom.
The Daniels kept as much of the original structure as feasible, including removing the cedar tongue-and-groove shiplap on the walls by hand, then painting and reinstalling it to lighten up the space. New beams were wrapped in cedar to match the siding. They gave the old brick fireplace a facelift, resurfacing it with stone that looked like it was gathered from the beach. For the mantle, they used a reclaimed piece of wood that they had carried around for a decade in the hope of finding a perfect spot for it. The original built-ins in the bedroom were preserved, as were the living room windows, including a picture window from the early 1900s that Mose had salvaged from the Frederick and Nelson department store building in downtown Seattle before it became Nordstrom.
The cabin’s 1,200 square-foot footprint stayed the same but was reconfigured to make it more livable. A bedroom was added, the bathrooms were remodeled, and the end of the house was opened up to make room for a big, beautiful kitchen with Rainier Honed Quartz counters, custom cabinetry, a granite sink, new appliances and a sweet coffee and wine bar. The Daniels vaulted the ceiling in the kitchen and covered it with tongue-andgroove cedar to match the living room. Off the kitchen, new French doors open out to a new deck. The cabin also needed updated plumbing and electrical as well as a new roof. All the interior doors are now solid-core wood with new black hardware. The exterior battenboard siding is painted bright white.
A team of local experts worked alongside the Daniels, including architect Charlie Wenzlau, Hauswerks, Day Road Electric and Swift Plumbing. Tom acted as general contractor and lists his contributions as grunt work, trim, painting, landscaping, hardware, detail work and writing checks.
One of the biggest upgrades, and one of Mo’s favorite elements, is the engineered hard oak wide-plank flooring. “It’s bomb-proof for being on the beach, plus you can sand this down three times over its lifetime,” she said. Since the renovation took place while the COVID pandemic was in full swing and the supply and delivery chain was dramatically disrupted, the Daniels personally picked up the wood flooring from the warehouse in a U-Haul, built a ramp to the deck, then carried and stacked it inside, a task Mo won’t soon forget.
After construction wrapped up, Mo decorated the cabin with a mix of old and new. “I wanted it to be fun and beachy and homey, but elegant, and a home that our kids can come back to,” she said. Besides visiting family, the Daniels use the cabin to house out-of-town guests and as an Airbnb.
Since putting the finishing touches on the property at the end of February, they have hosted a steady stream of Airbnb lodgers: three in March, three in April and more on the books. “Getting the first online review is something I'll never forget,” said Mo. “You try to think of everything, so it was really satisfying to see that someone loved it as much as we do.”
After the impromptu move and subsequent cabin renovation, Mo said the Daniels are done moving. “This is the start of a hopefully long, last chapter,” she said. “Anne told me, ‘I always thought they were going to have to carry me out of here,’ and I remember that because I say the same thing.
I joke and say they're going to have to put me out on the water and do a Viking sendoff like in Captain Fantastic.”
Several weeks ago, Dennon walked by the cabin and was able to see the whole renovation for the first time. “This is where she grew up for most of her life,” said Mo. Although the Daniels have remodeled homes before, Mo said “this was all different, this one was closest to my heart.” Tom concurred. “While working on the place—days, nights, weekends, with family, Maureen, our children, friends and contractors—the spirit and history was always front and center. I think knowing that family, friends, dogs and children are enjoying the same lifestyle provides some comfort, resolve and maybe even a smile on her face.”
In a recent email to Tom, Dennon wrote, “Your vision and the incredible labor involved created your wonderful new abode. You have done such a fabulous, thoughtful job! It has a personality all its own while harmonizing beautifully with some of its old bones. May the joy continue for years to come for the Daniels family.”
Well said, Anne.

