A COMFORTABLE ICON
The story behind BI’s most recognizable attire
BY LUCIANO MARANO | PHOTOS BY LUCIANO MARANO
One store. Nearly 50 years. And almost too many shirts to count.
The elements behind the iconic Bay Hay & Feed pattern—which, in addition to shirts, is found on aprons, hats and cups—are more involved than the deceptively simple design might suggest.
Five rows of neatly spaced horses—or llamas, fish, tractors, dogs, etc.—stamped in a vibrant color. That’s it. The concept isn’t difficult.
And yet, contained in that uncomplicated motif, perhaps the most easily identified and instantly recognizable symbol of Bainbridge Island, is the story of the local Rolling Bay institution and a testament to the importance of community.
“We have people come in and say, ‘I need to get a shirt!’ and when they walk away with it, they say, ‘Now I feel like I belong here,’” said Els Heyne.
Heyne, a longtime employee, purchased Bay Hay & Feed in January 2022, along with her husband, Jeff Groman, their daughter Devin Groman and son-in-law Nick Snyder.
“Since I’d been with the business for so long, it was an easy changeover for the employees, and the customers were relieved because they felt Bay Hay & Feed would not change,” Heyne said. “Bainbridge is very supportive of local businesses and it always has been.”
Opened in 1979 by Howard Block and Ce-Ann Parker, Bay Hay & Feed has become a paragon of island culture. It was Block who first masterminded the soon-to-be beloved shirts sometime around 1990, according to Heyne. “It started with just horses, I’m pretty sure,” she said. “We continue because the demand is there.”
Demand enough for about 30 different designs in total, not counting the many custom jobs the store regularly supplies for schools, clubs, businesses and even some events. Recently, an island-based bachelorette party decided to commemorate the occasion with an order of Bay Hay shirts made especially for the bride-to-be.
“We’re trying to work on new ones all the time,” said Devin Groman, who, along with her duties in the Market and Card sections of the store, is in charge of all things Bay Hay apparel.
“Everyone has a great idea—and there are so many great ideas!” she said. “Customers come to us constantly, and some of their suggestions are so fun, but you just can’t do them all because for every design you have to have them in X, Y, Z styles and several colors and many sizes. It takes a long time.”
The shirt’s influence has spread far beyond the boundaries of Bainbridge Island. Many customers have sent the store photos, posed in the renowned garb in some shockingly far-flung locales.
“We used to post on the website the pictures people sent us, but I just couldn’t keep up,” Heyne said. And the world map in which she used to pin pictures essentially disintegrated under the strain.
“Nowadays,” she said, “a lot of people post them on Instagram, so I just repost them.”
And it’s not just for the sake of pleasing folks back home that intrepid travelers bring along a shirt. “I often bring a Bay Hay T-shirt with me when I travel for the express purpose of finding those other people who will be like, ‘Oh my gosh, I know that place!’” Groman said. “And then you say, ‘How do you know Bainbridge?’ and you can have a fun conversation. In Italy, I was walking in a square and some people came up to me because I was wearing a shirt.”
Even as the stylish shirts have gained international fame and a new group of owners has assumed command, the core mission of the store remains unchanged, Groman said, focusing on seasonal offerings, local-centric thinking and old-fashioned customer satisfaction.
“It’s a one-stop shop,” she explained. “You can bring your kids, you can spend some time and there’s a little bit for everyone. It’s just a pleasant place to be. The café is right there, so there’s a little bit of just hanging out in the garden that happens, too.”
Bay Hay & Feed is located at 10355 NE Valley Road. More information is available by calling 206-842-2813 or visiting bayhayandfeed.com


